Note: My Centerstage review is here.
The American Dream Songbook is Bernstein's operetta "Trouble in Tahiti" and five new musical compositions. It's an attempt by Next Theatre's artistic director to wrap arms around the American musical theater canon. No two-hour show can adequately do that, of course, and selecting contemporary composers has its pitfalls. One of the chosen ones is Kevin O'Donnell, a talented local guy who definitely benefitted from proximity. He's written great stuff for two companies I respect: The House Theatre and The Hypocrites. His new piece "Fear of Failure" doesn't rise to that high bar. It's muddled, overly mannered, light as air while demanding to be taken seriously. The four other selections are an entertaining new-agey anthem, a funny and frivolous cabaret number, a comitragic pop ballad charting Britney Spears' rise and fall, and a lyrical meditation on growing up. I can only see the last of these still being performed a generation or two from now.
Still, this is a sharp night of musical entertainment, well sung and choreographed. Bernstein deserves his place at the table. Even "Tahiti," one of his minor works, is more affecting and accomplished than most of what's being churned out by Broadway, Broadway in Chicago, Vegas, and wherever else folks are shelling out ungodly sums for shiny happy crap.





